Thoughts on Australian ‘mummyblogging’/'mommyblogging’

by Miscellaneous Mum on June 29, 2009 · 9 comments

in Reading/Writing

I’ve been asked a few times lately to give my thoughts on the rise of mummyblogging / parenting blogs in Australia and the power and attention these are starting to get from marketing and PR companies. In all honesty, I’ve not been much help as this subject does not rate high up in my list of blogging priorities, and I doubt it ever will, so haven’t given it much thought.

Though once I sit down to ponder it, I realise it already consumes some of my time, and might do yours, too: you ask yourself what do I do about all these emails that keep pouring into my inbox, more and more often?  Do I ignore them? Do I respond? Should I expect compensation?

Or – and this is also asked – how is it you get them and I don’t? I might want these in order to develop my contacts list &/or scope for blogging potential?

The following is an assortment of ideas (and hopefully tips) that I have put together.

I feel I should state that I’m talking here about personal blogs. This is a personal blog and so I must use this as my only reference. It would be wrong to presume I speak for all kinds of blogs written by mothers, as they are so many out there that differ from being purely ‘personal’ so I just want to make that clear.

Question: why am I getting PR emails all of a sudden?

I think as blogging, and throw social media in there as well, is growing in significance in Australia, so has it also become important to certain companies to monitor these blogs and their writers in the hopes ‘they might work together’ some day. This means they hope you mention their stuff for free, or very little in return. They find you if you’ve been lucky enough to be mentioned on any or all of these top blogging lists, (here’s a new one) or also possibly if you feature on the blogroll of the women on these lists. I am on the lists mentioned above, which means I receive releases from both Australia and the United States.

Okay, so what do I do?

That’s really up to you. Most people I know hit delete immediately. I at least skim through the salutation and depending on how it’s addressed influences whether I keep reading. Here’s what I get in order from right to so wrong:

Dear Karen (fine)
Dear miscmum (um – my name IS on my blog, you know)
Dear Karlie (no, try again)
Hey there! (Hey back! Professional much?)
Dear Lady, Blog Owner, Administrator etcetc (blech)
No salutation at all

Then sometimes you might be offered products. Here’s another point: if you’re already affiliated with a blog ad network you might be contractually obligated NOT to do certain promotions or giveaways because they clash with advertisers that are already paying money to appear on your blog. So tread wisely. The same goes when you sign up to more than one ad network.

Let’s assume you’ve read the spiel and think hey this sounds okay, I might re-post this if they give me a free sample or it just seems like an exercise I might like to give a go. If this sounds like you, and here is my point, then go ahead if it works for you. Does it work for your readers? That’s another question entirely.

In the spirit of disclosure, I don’t think I’ve yet done something similar. The only exception is if I write a blog post for a charity that will make the charity money (something I did do recently). I’m not being negative in writing product reviews here, not at all. I understand a lot of people like to do it. I am just stressing you should do it with your eyes open and attentive to all pervading factors. If I were to do something like this in the future there would have to be some exceptional perks!

What I usually say to people who email me is: “If you want your product on miscmum.com I have ad space available for you to purchase. I do not do reviews.” Keep it short and sweet. Interestingly, since I’ve nutted out that philosophy I’ve been getting emails back saying, “Thank you for your honesty.” I then get offered tickets to a movie premiere. So you could be surprised.

And last, here’s something interesting:

These rates are based on the 2008 National Freelance Rates approved by the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance and apply to all genres except poetry. The rates are exclusive of GST.
Per day $813.00
Per half day (2/3 day rate) $542.00
Per hour $203.00
1000 words or less $829.00
Per word thereafter $0.83

This information is public. You can find it here. You mightn’t even have known it existed, which is forgiveable, but now you do. I should stress at this point that although these are the desired and approved rates  - and for freelancers it’s the per word rate which is typically most pertinent to their concerns - many publications don’t offer them: you are told, “We pay X per word” and it’s not negotiable. This is mostly tolerable because most often publications are reasonable. (And lucky you if you score a writing gig for an inflight magazine, as they often pay over $1 per word).

I mention all this because when I see the occasional job opening posted for paid blogging positions that offer as little as two cents a word, I can’t help but get slightly incredulous and confused. Why throw away your labour for next to nothing? I can certainly understand if the position were one that that would offer some kind of security, but even then there would have to be other consolations, such as if the subject were one you were passionate about.

The real point of this post – the bit where I sit here, chewing my nails, in thought – is how I feel this is connected to the wider social/feminist issues these questions raise about how mothers put a price on their labour and whether the returns are a) fair and b) worthwhile. Perhaps I’ve been burned too much by our former Howard government, who wanted nothing more than to hoik mothers out of the home and back into the ‘real’ workplace. I don’t feel the fact that our homes are real workplaces, too, with our own challenges, ambitions, frustrations and, yes, money-earning capacities ever got mentioned in their rhetoric.

I daresay I find this confusing because I find myself straddled between these two worlds. I make a little money, but not much (and certainly not as much as others). I’m fine with that. I don’t consider myself an expert. I’m fine with that, too.

I welcome your thoughts in the comments section. How do you feel? Have you got it all worked out or are you confused too? Do you think this subject gets talked about enough? Do you even feel like it is an issue or are you happy as you are?

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • Google
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

Rachel Hills (4 comments.) June 29, 2009 at 8:47 am

Yeah, those MEAA rates are deliciously, but ridiculously high. 83c/word would be good enough (I’ve only worked for one Australian publication that pays more than that rate – most pay around 50c, publications not affiliated with a big company often less), but over $800 for any piece of writing less than 1000 words? We’re dreaming.

I’ve heard that a lot of these “pay for post” deals can actually pay very well (as well as corporate writing, even), but I also worry that they exploit the relationship built up between blogger and reader, particularly in the case of personal blogs. Obviously any paid posts would need to be marked as such.

jen (46 comments.) June 29, 2009 at 10:53 am

I’ve setup a reviews/giveaways section on my blog because I started getting these PR emails. I also removed the ads from that section that would have clashed with these reviews. I’ve got some free stuff out of it and I’ve given away stuff but it certainly hasn’t meant a huge boost in traffic or readership for me. I do notice that people do find my reviews via search terms so the long-term effects for marketers are probably pretty good for some products.

Some things haven’t worked out. For instance, I wrote a blog post for another blog and I think mine was the first and the last blog post for that blog. The idea was there but the execution wasn’t. So you’ve gotta be careful you only do what you can and don’t bust a gut for hardly any reward for yourself.

Mistress B (53 comments.) June 29, 2009 at 1:03 pm

I have some serious objections to the policy of the Howard government in regards to devaluing the work of mothers in the home. I feel very blessed that my husband earns enough that we are not subject to those rules and have the freedom to make a choice. I have many friends who don’t and it really disgusts me the lack of compassion, understanding, flexibility and fairness that is shown to these women….. but that’s a rant for another place

I’ve accepted a few free products but on the understanding that I would write a review IF I wanted to and would not guarantee that it would be positive. I haven’t had any for a while though but I think that had more to do with changing to self hosted so dropping in some of the lists. But for me it’s been a bit of fun, I don’t blog with the intention of making money so any that does show up is a bonus!

Stacie (1 comments.) June 29, 2009 at 3:54 pm

I don’t really know how I feel. I love doing the product reviews. I have my first giveaway up and am rather discouraged that no one is really signing up. I haven’t blogged for money as I didn’t think it would be worth it and it would take away the fun. I love blogging and meeting new people. I guess maybe you can say I am confused by it.

Karen June 29, 2009 at 4:09 pm

Rachel – Yes, Paid posts are also popular – I believe – as they often get traffic targeted by some means to those particular posts? (I’ve never done them for reasons you said – except once for charity)

Jen – Sounds like you’ve thought about it though and worked out a system. That sounds encouraging.

Mistress B – Your last sentence sounds like you’ve got a nice philosopht. If you were going to write the rant, you must send me the link ;)

Stacie- Yes, I once did something similar. Its a bit embarrassing, isn’t it? Hope you aren’t confused for too long.

Trish (24 comments.) June 29, 2009 at 10:06 pm

I recently did my first ever product review and I wont be doing another one. It was a complete waste of my time. None of the posts that reviewed the product range were commented on by any of my regular readers, and I didn’t experience any spike in reader numbers. The PR agency have been sporadic in keeping in touch with me and promises regarding link-backs from their product website have not been kept. I will not do it again, but if I ever get my name on the Top 100 list I might consider adding an advertising banner or sidebar.

Karen June 30, 2009 at 8:20 am

I’m sorry you had a bad experience Trish :(

Susan @ ReadingUpsideDown (15 comments.) June 30, 2009 at 5:23 pm

Thanks for this interesting post, Karen.

I share two blogs with a friend (Meredith). One, Reading Upside Down, is a book blog. I do receive review copies of books, which I guess is similar to receiving products to review. I also review books that I already own and books that I borrow from my local library.

The other blog, Oh the Thinks you can Think, is a personal blog.

Both Meredith and I are at home full time. We are fortunate that we each have a husband who is able to provide enough income that we can make this choice, although we have both had to make numerous sacrifices to remain within the limitations of being a one income family.

I have browsed a few of the pay-to-blog formats. While the idea of earning money from blogging appeals to me quite a lot (actually earning some extra money appeals to me enormously), I don’t really feel comfortable with any of the formats. When I visit blogs that have embedded links for products and businesses I always feel a little edgy about how sincere or natural the writing is. I wouldn’t want people to get that impression from our blogs.

I do write for an online magazine where I earn a percentage of ad-click revenue. These posts are written in third person and never reflect anything personal.

I guess my ideal would be to gain freelance writing opportunities separate to my blogging. I love receiving the ARC books and feel that they give me the opportunity to review books and authors I wouldn’t otherwise have easy access to, but don’t really want to venture into the realms of comissioned blog posts or product reviews.

katef (32 comments.) July 6, 2009 at 10:07 pm

It’s an interesting topic…. I’ve read Us ‘Mom bloggers’ being given cars to review and wondered if that would ever filter through to us over here. So far the only thing I’ve been asked to review is a laxative… um… er… I guess that sums up my blog! LOL

Leave a Comment

Previous post: Writing vs Mothering

Next post: This post is not about Michael Jackson. Not really.